With better economic opportunities in urban India, there has been an exponential growth in the urban population, especially in the unorganized slums. According to Census 2011, the urban population is around 31% in India. However the health infrastructure in urban slums remains poor.With “farmers” being the ‘holy grail in Indian Politics’, public health programmes have always been traditionally focussed on rural areas. In fact there is no definite health system in urban India. A multitude of agencies are involved with delivery of health care in towns and cities often leading to a scenario where confusion reigns and inequitable access to health care rules. The fast growth in urban population in general and the urban poor in particular, has lead to unplanned growth. Hence, it is vital that the urban health be given the due importance. Realising this, the government has already conceived for NUHM (National Urban Health Mission).
NUHM will be able to address the issue of deficiency in health infrastructure and manpower in urban poor areas. NUHM promises to provide a quality primary health care system in urban areas especially to the population living in urban slums and unauthorised colonies. NUHM unlike previous healthcare programmes promised to take a wholesome view of health and rely heavily on technology. It promises to focus on issues safe water and sanitation in addition to focus on bridging the gross inequity in healthcare accessibility and affordability . NUHM will have city-specific plans and use geo-spatial satellite pictures to find out slums and slum-like inhabitations and not on human intelligence which is liable to political interference.
Major Health problems in Urban India and NUHM
The NFHS-3 has clearly highlighted the plight of the urban poor .According to NFHS-3 the urban poorest are three times more likely to die before attaining the age of 5 years, 20 times more likely not to have any antenatal care, 3 times less likely to get primary immunization, and 2.5 to 3 times more likely to be stunted and wasted than urban richest.
Major health problems in urban area are significantly different from that of rural areas. Non-communicable diseases , mental health and occupational injury will be of prime focus in NUHM . Nutritional deficiency, maternal and child health problems as in rural areas is a major problem in urbane locations too. Environmental health related to water quality and sanitation and also air pollution leading to the ever increasing incidence of asthma, COPD and other respiratory illness are other problems unique to the urban scenario.
Cost, timings, distance, attitude of health providers, and other factors put the secondary care and private sector facilities out of reach of most of the poor urban residents. Unlike in rural areas where facilities are non-existent all together urban areas usually have adequate healthcare facilities in the private sector. However studies have clearly pointed out that when the urban poor access private facilities, the significant cost incurred leads to severe debt. NUHM is properly implemented will thus help the urban poor to have lesser out of pocket health spending. “Other factors contributing to the inadequate reach of services are illegality, social exclusion of slums, hidden slum pockets, weak social fabric, lack of coordination among various stakeholders, and neglected political consciousness”. ( Yadav K, Nikhil SV, Pandav CS , IJCM 2011;36:3-7) With use of technology NUHM will also help in identifying and addressing the issues of immigration and emigration and ensure that primary health care is not denied to anyone.
Another factor aggravating the poor health scenario of the urban slum population is lack of intra-sectoral and inter-sectoral coordination. Urban locals typically have a multitude of bodies working on issues like water and sanitation, nutrition, and maternal and child health etc. These bodies involve various stakeholders, including the government, NGOs, corporate and private sector organizations, that operate on their ‘own free will’ without any coordination and convergence leading to a scenario where some people get spoilt over health facilities whereas others are left wanting for any.
The NUHM vide the Urban Social Health Activist (USHA) and Mahila Arogya Samitis (MAS) will facilitate improved access to public and private health services at the community level and instigate community risk pooling, linked where feasible, to an insurance mechanism, as also to provide smart cards to the family, to ensure access to quality health care. ( Yadav K, Nikhil SV, Pandav CS , IJCM 2011;36:3-7)
A Step Closer to Universal Health Coverage
With the Prime Minister of India expressing his desire to make NUHM a component of the unified National Health Mission and the allocation of more than INR 40,000 crores on this account for the next three years it only seems natural that India will soon see the light of Universal Health Coverage – “an India where no one will die for lack of health facilities.”
Pic Courtesy : http://www.fotopedia.com/items/flickr-2646605599 under Creative Common Attribution-NonCommercial 2.0 Generic (CC BY-NC 2.0)
A revised and updated version of this article has been published at Your Health of Indian Medical Association.
Dr. Bhaumik, this is a fascinating article. There are a lot of corollaries between issues in India and America. There is no good reason why we cannot have universal health coverage in either country. Keep posting, my friend.
Thank You for your insight. While it is true that there are some corollaries yet the two countries have very different health systems both with certain fundamental flaws. While some of them are correctable I believe they wont ever be owing to the lack of understtanding as well as will of politicians. In India another major factor is corruption.
Interesting. I hope to do more research on the subject in the coming months. I am still very much an outsider to the healthcare culture. However, the move in the US towards mandated insurance is, i hope, prophetic. You’re right, though, about politics and it makes me sick that the powerful prey on the weak.
That is the rule of the planet. Remember Darwin “the fittest shall survive” . Politics is not bad.., human beings are.. Do share your views. Why not send me a Guest Post on your views as an outsider in US on any issue of public health/health system/policy. I did be glad .
Sure! Just so you know, I am not yet a physician. I will be starting medical school next fall. I am however a trained scientist and I am very aware of the political situation here in the US. I will polish up a post in a week and get back to you.
That is not an issue. Degrees are just to showcase. True knowledge is independent of where you are. Drop me a mail at soumyadeepbhaumik@rediffmail.com . Send me ur ID . You are welcome to send me blog posts. I will start a guest editorial section with you . Cheers 🙂